The State of Origin teams have been named, and it's a fascinating selection process that has sparked debate among fans and experts alike. As an expert analyst, I'm here to dissect the selections and provide my insights and commentary on the 19-man squads for NSW and Queensland.
NSW: A Balanced Blend of Experience and X-Factor
Fullback: Dylan Edwards
I believe Dylan Edwards is the right choice at fullback. His Penrith connection with Nathan Cleary is undeniable, and their understanding of each other's game is a huge advantage. Edwards' form this year has been exceptional, and he's currently ahead of James Tedesco in the Dally M Medal count. His ability to know when to overplay his hand, as Tedesco sometimes does, is a valuable skill in Origin football.
Winger: Brian To'o and Campbell Graham
Brian To'o is a clear choice for the left wing. His set-starting ability and finishing prowess make him a force to be reckoned with. Campbell Graham, on the other hand, is a more contentious pick. While he's a hard worker and a great defender, his temperament and ability to handle pressure make him a strong candidate for the right wing.
Centres: Latrell Mitchell and Kotoni Staggs
The battle for the right centre spot is intriguing. Stephen Crichton, despite his injury concerns, is a skilled player. However, Kotoni Staggs has been in excellent form for the Broncos and is a blockbusting presence on the field. The decision to start Staggs over Crichton, despite the latter's injury, is a bold one, but it showcases the coach's faith in Staggs' fitness and form.
Halves: Ethan Strange and Nathan Cleary
I'm surprised by the decision to pair Mitchell Moses and Nathan Cleary in the halves. While Moses has been in good form, I believe Ethan Strange deserves a chance. His fearless approach and performance against Penrith last round scream Origin readiness. Partnering Strange with Cleary could help the latter dominate at Origin level, as he's taken his game to another level this season.
Front Row: Keaon Koloamatangi and Mitch Barnett
Mitch Barnett is a perfect fit for the front row. His toughness and ability to play harder as the game gets tougher make him a strong pick. Keaon Koloamatangi, a metre-eater with great form, completes the front row. The decision to start them over Addin Fonua-Blake is a strategic one, given the changed Origin eligibility rules.
Hooker: Blayke Brailey
Blayke Brailey is a strong contender for the hooker spot. His defensive prowess and ability to play behind the Roosters pack make him a valuable asset. Tom Starling, on the bench, provides a backup dummy half option, offering unpredictability and a willingness to charge out of the line.
Back-Row: Hudson Young and Haumole Olakau'atu
The back-row spots are a no-brainer for Hudson Young and Haumole Olakau'atu. Their form this year has been impressive, with Olakau'atu's improved performance since Kieran Foran's arrival at Manly.
Lock: Isaah Yeo or Cam Murray
The choice between Isaah Yeo and Cam Murray is a minor one, as both players are capable of starting at lock. The team's strength remains unaffected by this decision.
Bench: Tom Starling, Cameron Murray, Angus Crichton, Jackson Ford, James Tedesco, Mitchell Moses
The bench provides cover for various positions, with Tom Starling and Cameron Murray offering depth. Angus Crichton and Jackson Ford provide options for the middle or edge positions, while James Tedesco and Mitchell Moses are on the extended bench to ensure cover for the backline.
Queensland: A Balanced Blend of Experience and X-Factor
Fullback: Kalyn Ponga
Kalyn Ponga's recent form for the Knights has been exceptional, and his danger around the ball makes him a must-start fullback. Reece Walsh, while talented, might be a riskier choice, especially with Ponga's current form.
Winger: Selwyn Cobbo and Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow
Selwyn Cobbo's call-up for the injured Xavier Coates is a strategic move. Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow's shift to the wing makes way for Ponga, showcasing the team's ability to adapt.
Centres: Jaxon Purdue and Robert Toia
Jaxon Purdue's recent push from Billy Slater adds intrigue. Robert Toia's handling of Latrell Mitchell last year was impressive, and the pace of Queensland's centres is a strength.
Halves: Cameron Munster and Sam Walker
Cameron Munster's return to form is a welcome sight, and Sam Walker's short kicking game and instinctive style make him a perfect fit for Origin. The decision to start Walker over Daly Cherry-Evans is a strategic one, given the latter's age and recent form.
Front Row: Tino Fa'asualeaui and Pat Carrigan
Pat Carrigan's partnership with Tino Fa'asualeaui is a strong choice, especially with Josh Papalii's absence. The decision to start Carrigan is a risk-free move, given his recent performances.
Hooker: Harry Grant
Harry Grant is the best dummy-half in the game, and his selection is automatic.
Back-Row: Reuben Cotter and Kurt Capewell
Reuben Cotter and Kurt Capewell's back-row combination from last year is a solid choice. Their defensive prowess and ability to lock down opponents are valuable assets.
Lock: Trent Loiero
Trent Loiero's pick-and-stick mentality might get him the nod at lock, despite his recent struggles for the Storm. The team's famous strategy could be a factor in his selection.
Bench: Max Plath, Kulikefu Finefeuiaki, Lindsay Collins, Tom Flegler, Reece Walsh, Kurt Mann
The bench provides depth and utility, with Max Plath and Tom Flegler slowly returning to form. Lindsay Collins' recent head knock adds a layer of risk, while Reece Walsh and Kurt Mann offer outstanding utility value.
